Pleural Effusion

Pleural effusion: transudate versus exudate and Light's criteria, causes, clinical features, investigations including pleural fluid analysis, and management.

Orientation notes for study. Check local guidelines before prescribing or performing procedures.

Definition

A pleural effusion is an abnormal collection of fluid in the pleural space (between the visceral and parietal pleura). Normally only 5–15 mL of fluid is present.

Mechanisms

  • Increased hydrostatic pressure (heart failure) → transudate.
  • Decreased oncotic pressure (low albumin) → transudate.
  • Increased capillary permeability or inflammation (infection, cancer) → exudate.
  • Impaired lymphatic drainage (malignancy) → exudate.
  • Fluid passing from the abdomen (ascites, peritoneal dialysis) → transudate.

Causes: transudate versus exudate

Transudate (protein below 30 g/L)Exudate (protein above 30 g/L)
Heart failure (commonest, bilateral)Pneumonia (parapneumonic effusion, empyema)
Cirrhosis (hepatic hydrothorax)Tuberculosis (very common in Kenya, HIV)
Nephrotic syndrome, hypoalbuminaemiaMalignancy (lung, breast, lymphoma, mesothelioma, metastases)
HypothyroidismPulmonary embolism
Peritoneal dialysisRheumatoid arthritis, SLE
Meigs syndromePancreatitis, oesophageal rupture
Constrictive pericarditisAsbestos-related, drugs (amiodarone, nitrofurantoin)

Light's criteria (an exudate if ANY one is met)

  • Pleural fluid protein / serum protein above 0.5
  • Pleural fluid LDH / serum LDH above 0.6
  • Pleural fluid LDH above two-thirds of the upper limit of the normal serum LDH

Clinical features

  • Symptoms: progressive dyspnoea, pleuritic chest pain (may disappear as fluid separates the pleura), dry cough; plus symptoms of the cause (fever, weight loss, orthopnoea).
  • Signs: stony dull percussion, reduced or absent breath sounds, reduced tactile vocal fremitus over the effusion; bronchial breathing at the upper edge; trachea and mediastinum pushed away if large; reduced chest expansion.

Investigations

  • Chest X-ray: blunting of the costophrenic angle (needs about 200 mL on PA view), meniscus sign; large effusion causes "white-out" with contralateral shift.
  • Ultrasound: confirms fluid, shows septations, and guides aspiration.
  • CT chest: pleural thickening, nodules, masses, loculation.
  • Diagnostic pleural aspiration (thoracentesis): send for
    • Appearance (clear straw, bloody, pus, milky).
    • Protein and LDH (Light's criteria), glucose (low in TB, rheumatoid, empyema, malignancy), pH (below 7.2 suggests empyema needing drainage).
    • Cell count and differential: neutrophils (acute infection), lymphocytes (TB, cancer).
    • Cytology (malignant cells), culture and Gram stain, AFB and GeneXpert, ADA (adenosine deaminase) high in TB.
    • Triglycerides (chylothorax), amylase (pancreatic).
  • Pleural biopsy (image-guided or thoracoscopic) if the diagnosis is still unclear.
  • Treat the cause: echocardiography, LFTs, albumin, urine protein.

Management

  1. Treat the underlying cause: diuretics for heart failure, anti-TB treatment, antibiotics for infection, chemotherapy for cancer.
  2. Therapeutic aspiration for symptom relief (ultrasound-guided, stop at about 1.5 L or when the patient coughs or has chest tightness, to avoid re-expansion pulmonary oedema).
  3. Parapneumonic effusion and empyema: antibiotics plus chest drain if pus, pH below 7.2, positive Gram stain or culture, or loculation; fibrinolytics or surgical decortication if it fails.
  4. Malignant effusion: repeated aspiration, pleurodesis (talc) or an indwelling pleural catheter for recurrent effusions; treat the cancer.
  5. TB pleurisy: full anti-TB regimen; effusion usually resolves.
  6. Avoid sedatives in large effusions; oxygen if hypoxic.

Complications

  • Empyema, pleural thickening and fibrosis (trapped lung), respiratory failure, re-expansion pulmonary oedema, pneumothorax and bleeding from aspiration.

Exam points

  • Transudate = systemic (heart, liver, kidney); exudate = local pleural or lung disease.
  • Light's criteria separates them.
  • Low pleural glucose points to TB, rheumatoid, empyema, malignancy.
  • pH below 7.2 needs a chest drain.
  • Lymphocytic, high ADA effusion in Kenya: think TB.
  • Always aspirate under ultrasound guidance.

Pharmacology at a glance

Tap a drug name for its full card (how it works, adverse effects, cautions, dose), then use Back to this note to return to this spot.

DrugClassRole hereWatch for
FurosemideLoop diureticEffusion from heart failureLow potassium and sodium, dehydration
RifampicinAnti-TB drugTuberculous pleural effusion, as part of the standard regimenHepatitis, orange urine, many interactions
CeftriaxoneThird-generation cephalosporinParapneumonic effusion and empyemaBiliary sludge, allergy
MetronidazoleNitroimidazoleAnaerobic cover in empyemaMetallic taste; no alcohol
ParacetamolAnalgesicPleuritic painLiver injury in overdose

Drain, do not just drug: a pleural pH below 7.2, pus or a positive culture needs a chest drain as well as antibiotics.

Practice questions

1. A 45-year-old woman with HIV has fever, weight loss and a unilateral effusion: protein 52 g/L, lymphocytes predominant, glucose low, ADA high. The most likely diagnosis is: A. Heart failure · B. Tuberculous pleural effusion · C. Nephrotic syndrome · D. Cirrhosis · E. Pulmonary embolism Answer: B.

2. A pleural fluid pH of 6.9 with a positive Gram stain in a patient with pneumonia should be treated with: A. Diuretics · B. Antibiotics and an urgent chest drain · C. Observation · D. Steroids · E. Talc pleurodesis Answer: B. Empyema.

3. Which finding classifies a pleural effusion as an exudate? A. Pleural LDH/serum LDH 0.4 · B. Pleural protein/serum protein 0.7 · C. Pleural protein 20 g/L only · D. Clear fluid · E. Bilateral effusions Answer: B.

More in Respiratory

All study notes

Compiled by Abongo Davis · Ompath Study · shared for MBChB students at Mount Kenya University and other universities.